I've been eating at OTP since 1976. The quality and unique service is always a treat

I've had decent pizza here before when ordering a complete pizza. It's not the best I've had, but certainly not terrible, either. The atmosphere of the place is nice, especially at night.

What IS terrible is the couple of times I've dropped by during lunchtime to have a slice or two, which has been dry and cardboard-like. Do yourself a favor and avoid their pizza by the slice, unless you know it has just been cooked.

The reviews on this place are clearly mixed, but we had a discount coupon and gave it a try. The place has "atmosphere", to be sure, but the food was disappointing. Arrived on a Friday evening to find they were out of caesar salad, out of root beer (!), and a 40 minute wait for pizza. Ordering is confusing - stand in line to order, then take a playing card and head for the bar, where you order drinks and pay for the lot. Then compete for a table to open up. Tables are cramped with little leg room. Seats are quaint, but uncomfortable.

Ordered a salad and veggie pizza. Salad arrived reasonably promptly, but very uninspired. Pizza arrived much later, not horrible but not that good (definitely better than Dominos, worse than many). Service OK but busy and stressed.

Parking is a big problem, as noted elsewhere. The facility may be historic, but it is also run down. I don't think they have invested in it in decades.

Overall, an unremarkable experience. They have better pizza in the freezer case at Safeway. If you go, go for the "atmosphere", but not for the food!

One of the more interesting pizza places in town. Their pizza tends to be a little on the greasy and garlic side, but not a bad pizza at all. They put mega toppings on which is great, but with the thin crust it can get a bit messy. It's good pizza, but it's also a lot of work.

We really enjoy this pizza. The location is interesting on occasion. There is always lots going on in the neighborhood. The atmosphere is unique and comfortable. The pizza is very good and service good too. It is a bit grungy around the edges but doesn't seem out of place since it is in old town. Sometimes parking can be challenging. Prices are good.